Discount stores’ sales tied to more women smoking while pregnant, study finds
By Doug Bennett
Tobacco sales at two national dollar store chains may have negatively impacted the smoking rate among pregnant women in the Southeast United States, UF Health researchers have found.
Smoking during pregnancy was found to be associated with increased tobacco availability at thousands of dollar stores in the region, the study concluded. The findings have been published in the journal JAMA Pediatrics.
“The rate of smoking during pregnancy has been coming down, but rates are nearing stagnation in counties that have the greatest increases in tobacco availability due to this change in corporate policies of the dollar stores,” said Jaclyn Hall, Ph.D., an assistant research scientist in the UF College of Medicine’s department of health outcomes and biomedical informatics, and lead author of the study.
To establish their findings, the researchers used publicly available data to track smoking habits and shifting tobacco sales policies at a major pharmacy and several dollar store chains. In late 2012 and early 2013, the nation’s two largest dollar store chains started selling tobacco products in approximately 8,300 southeastern stores. Two years later, the nation’s largest pharmacy chain ended tobacco sales at its 2,500 stores. As a net result of these policy changes, access to tobacco products across the region increased.
The researchers looked at trends from 2011-12 and 2015-16 in counties of six large southeastern states, including Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina and Tennessee, and concluded that increased access to tobacco may be inhibiting programs to help reduce tobacco use even after factors such as sociodemographics and tobacco-control efforts were considered. The researchers chose the Southeast because dollar stores are most prevalent in this region, and smoking rates are among the highest in the nation.
Smoking during pregnancy is one of the leading preventable causes of negative birth outcomes such as premature birth and low birth weight, Hall noted. The study found the biggest declines in the rate of smoking during pregnancy occurred in counties that had no increase in tobacco retailers or even a decline in the number of stores due to the pharmacy’s decision not to sell.
“This study shows that a large retailer’s decision about selling tobacco products can have a profound impact, positive or negative, on community health,” Hall said. “It would greatly change the tobacco retail landscape if other pharmacies and companies stopped selling tobacco and demonstrated their commitment to Americans’ health.”
After controlling for demographic variables and smoke-free laws, changes in the number and concentration of tobacco retailers was the most significant factor in the rate of decline of smoking during pregnancy, the researchers found. Among pregnant women in lower-income communities, smoking rates fell only 3.6 percent in areas where tobacco retailers increased the most, while the rate fell 12 percent in areas with smaller increases in tobacco retailers.
The same trend was found in high-income communities: Smoking rates for pregnant women declined 20.3 percent in areas with smaller increases in tobacco retailers — more than twice the improvement that was found in places where tobacco sellers proliferated.
“The six states that we studied all declined to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act,’’ Hall said. “Expanding health coverage would have offered more clinical smoking-cessation programs to low-income individuals.”
The findings could be used by local officials to develop property zoning and tobacco sale licensing guidelines to reduce clusters of tobacco retailers, especially near schools, said Ramzi Salloum, Ph.D., an assistant professor of health outcomes and biomedical informatics and senior author of the study. Counties could enact density rules for tobacco sellers similar to the regulations on bars, he said. Likewise, states should consider adequate funding for smoking cessation and health communications programs, the researchers noted.
Next, the researchers plan to further analyze information about tobacco retailing and smoking habits at the neighborhood level. That, Salloum said, could help guide policy decisions about the concentration of tobacco retailers in communities.
“The action by these dollar stores goes against decades of progress in tobacco control and compromises that progress,” he said. “It’s contributing to the disparities in smoking rates in the communities where dollar stores are prevalent.”
The findings of this study indicate a cause for concern about rates of tobacco use in the U.S. and other negative health consequences associated with tobacco use, such as cancer. The study was released just one week after the American Cancer Society reported that progress in smoking rates had the greatest contribution to improved cancer mortality rates.
UF Health News intern Kacey Finch contributed to this report.